IS SELF-DECEPTION PRETENSE?
Palavras-chave:Self-deception. Belief. Imagination. Pretense. Make-believe. The aim of belief. Truth-directedness. Motivation. Action
ResumoI assess Tamar Gendler’s (2007) account of self-deception according to which its characteristic state is not belief, but imaginative pretense. After giving an overview of the literature and presenting the conceptual puzzles engendered by the notion of selfdeception, I introduce Gendler’s account, which emerges as a rival to practically all extant accounts of self-deception. I object to it by first arguing that her argument for abandoning belief as the characteristic state of self-deception conflates the state of belief and the process of belief-formation when interpreting David Velleman’s (2000) thesis that belief is an essentially truth-directed attitude. I then call attention to the fact that Velleman’s argument for the identity of motivational role between belief and imagining, on which Gendler’s argument for self-deception as pretense depends, conflates two senses of ‘motivational role’—a stronger but implausible sense and a weaker but explanatorily irrelevant sense. Finally, I introduce Neil Van Leeuwen’s (2009) argument to the effect that belief is the practical ground of all non-belief cognitive attitudes in circum-stances wherein the latter prompt action. I apply this framework to Gendler’s account to ultimately show that imaginative pretense fails to explain the existence of voluntary actions which result from self-deception.
AUDI, R. Self-Deception, Action, and Will. Erkenntnis 18: 133–58, 1982.
BAYNE, T. and FERNÁNDEZ, J. Delusion and Self-Deception: Affective and Motivational Influences on Belief Formation. Psychology Press, 2009.
BARNES, A. Seeing through Self-Deception. Cambridge University Press. In: Bayne, T. and Fernández, J., (eds.) (2009). Delusion and Self-Deception: Affective and Motivational Influences on Belief Formation. Psychology Press.
BORGE, S. The myth of self-deception. Southern Journal of Philosophy 41: 1–28, 2003.
BORTOLOTTI, L. and Mameli, M. Self-Deception, Delusion and the Boundaries of Folk Psychology. Humana.Mente, 20: 203–221, 2012.
BRATMAN, M.E. Practical Reasoning and Acceptance in a Context. Mind 101 (401): 1-16, 1992.
CANFIELD, J.V. and Gustafson, D.F. Self-Deception. Analysis 23: 32– 36, 1962.
CARSON, T. L. Lying, Deception, and Related Concepts. In: C.W. Martin, (eds.) (2009), The Philosophy of Deception. Oxford University Press.
CHERNIAK, C. Minimal Rationality. MIT Press, 1986.
CURRIE, G. and RAVENSCROFT, I. Recreative Minds: Imagination in Philosophy and Psychology. Oxford University Press, 2002.
DARWIN, C. The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex. Princeton University Press, 1871/1981.
DAVIDSON, D. Deception and Division. In: J. Elster, (eds.) (1985), The Multiple Self. Cambridge University Press.
DAVIES, M. Delusion and Motivationally Biased Belief: SelfDeception in the Two-Factor Framework. In: T. Bayne and J.
Fernández, (eds.) (2009) Delusion and Self-Deception: Affective and Motivational Influences on Belief Formation. Psychology Press.
DEMOS, R. Lying to Oneself. Journal of Philosophy, 57: 588–95, 1960.
ELSTER J. The Multiple Self. Cambridge University Press, 1985.
EVANS, J. St. B. T. and FRANKISH, K., (eds.) (2009). In Two Minds: Dual Processes and Beyond. Oxford University Press.
FREUD, S. A Childhood Recollection from Dichtung und Wahrheit. In: J. Strachey et al., (eds.) (1917/1958), The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud. Hogarth Press.
GENDLER, T.S. Self-deception as pretense. Philosophical Perspectives 21 (Philosophy of Mind), 231–258, 2007.
GENDLER, T.S. Alief and Belief. Journal of Philosophy 105, 634–663, 2008.
GERGEN, K. The Ethnopsychology of Self-Deception. In: M. Martin, (eds.) (1985), Self-Deception and Self-Understanding. University of Kansas Press.
HAIGHT, M. A Study of Self-Deception. Harvester Press, 1980.
HOORENS, V. Self-enhancement and Superiority Biases in Social Comparison. European Review of Social Psychology, 4(1): 113–139, JOHNSTON, M. Self-Deception and the Nature of Mind. In: B. McLaughlin and A. Rorty, (eds.) (1988), Perspectives on SelfDeception. University of California Press.
KAHNEMAN, D. Thinking, Fast and Slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011.
KANT, I. The Metaphysics of Morals, trans. M.J. Gregor. Cambridge University Press, 1797/1996.
KIPP, D. On Self-Deception. Philosophical Quarterly, 30: 305–17, 1980.
KRUGER, J. and DUNNING, D. Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One’s Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77(6): 1121–34, 1999.
LAZAR, A. Deceiving Oneself or Self-Deceived? On the Formation of Beliefs ‘Under the Influence.’ Mind 108: 265–90, 1999.
MARTIN C. W. The Philosophy of Deception. Oxford University Press, 2009.
MARTIN, M. W. Self-Deception, Self-Pretence, and Emotional Detachment. Mind 88: 441-446, 1979.
MARTIN, M. W. Self-Deception and Self-Understanding. University of Kansas Press, 1985.
MARTIN, M. W. Self-deception and Morality. Kansas University Press, 1986.
MCKAY, R., LANGDON, R. and COLTHEART, M. “Sleights of Mind”: Delusion and Self-Deception. In: T. Bayne and J. Fernández, (eds.) (2009) Delusion and Self-Deception: Affective and Motivational Influences on Belief Formation. Psychology Press.
MCLAUGHLIN B. and RORTY A. Perspectives on Self-Deception. University of California Press, 1988.
MELE, A.R. Self-Deception Unmasked. Princeton University Press, 2001.
MICHEL, C. and NEWEN, A. Self-Deception as Pseudo-Rational Regulation of Belief. Consciousness and Cognition 19 (3): 731-744, 2010.
MILLER, D. T. and ROSS, M. Self-serving biases in the attribution of causality: Fact or fiction? Psychological Bulletin, 82, 213-225, 1975.
MORAN, R. Authority and Estrangement. Princeton University Press, 2001.
NEU, J. Life-Lies and Pipe Dreams: Self-Deception in Ibsen’s The Wild Duck and O’Neill’s The Iceman Cometh. In A Tear Is an Intellectual Thing. Oxford University Press, 2000.
O’BRIEN, L. Imagination and the motivational view of belief. Analysis 65 (285): 55–62, 2005.
PEARS, D. Motivated Irrationality. Oxford University Press, 1984.
PORCHER, J. E. Against the Deflationary Account of Self-Deception. Humana.Mente, 20: 67–84, 2012.
RAMSEY, F. P. The Foundations of Mathematics and Other Logical Essays. Routledge, 1931.
REY, G. Toward a computational account of akrasia and selfdeception. In: B. McLaughlin and A. Rorty, (eds.) (1988), Perspectives on Self-Deception. University of California Press.
SARTRE, J. P. Being and Nothingness, trans. H. Barnes. Pocket Books, 1949/1957.
SMULLYAN, R. M. Logicians who reason about themselves. In Proceedings of the 1986 Conference on Theoretical Aspects of Reasoning bout Knowledge. Morgan Kaufmann, 1986.
STRACHEY J. et al. The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud. Hogarth Press, 1917/1958.
VAN LEEUWEN, D. S. N. The Product of Self-Deception. Erkenntnis 67(3), 419–437, 2007.
VAN LEEUWEN, D. S. N. The Motivational Role of Belief. Philosophical Papers 38(2), 219– 246, 2009.
VELLEMAN, J. D. On the Aim of Belief. In The Possibility of Practical Reason. Oxford University Press, 2009.
VELLEMAN, J. D. and SHAH, N. Doxastic deliberation. Philosophical Review 114: 497–534, 2005.