Reply to “predictive processing and the semiological principle:

commentary to duffley”



Semiological function of language, Semantics - Pragmatics interface, Abstraction, Embodiment of meaning, Contextualism


My notion of stable word meaning could correspond either to the root-node or the whole of a neurally-organized package and acknowledge that linguistic processing is largely holistic. The existence of words as context-free entities is not just a “cognitive idealization” however but a necessity, as otherwise speakers would have to make up their words on the spot. Holistic language processing undermines a sequential processing paradigm (first linguistic, then pragmatic). However, my model is only sequential in that linguistic-semantic units pre-exist their use and does not entail that a whole sentence must be assembled before pragmatic processing starts. The authors falsely suggest that I do not endorse a distinction between semantics and pragmatics. While I do argue that this distinction cannot be based on the sentence/utterance distinction, I hold that a clear dividing-line can be drawn between semiologically-signified and non-semiologically-signified content. I disagree that “even highly abstract, monosemic words like any should be seen as embodied, ” so that the mental process of random selection must be construed “in (complex) sensorimotor terms”. While one can form an image of someone picking out an apple from a basket, one cannot argue that one must do so in order to use any.


Não há dados estatísticos.

Biografia do Autor

Patrick Duffley, Laval University

Researcher in the Department of Languages, Linguistics and Translation at Laval University.


Carston, R. (2008), Thoughts and Utterances: the Pragmatics of Explicit Communication, London, John Wiley and Sons.

Davidson, D. (1986), “A Nice Derangement of Epitaphs”, in E. Lepore (ed.), Truth and Interpretation: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson, Oxford, Blackwell, 433-446.

Duffley, P. J. (2014), Reclaiming Control As a Semantic and Pragmatic Phenomenon, Amsterdam/Philadelphia, John Benjamins.

Duffley, P. J. and P. Larrivée (2015), “A Fresh Look at the Compatibility between any and Veridical Contexts: the Quality of Indefiniteness Is Not Strained”, Lingua 158, 35-53.

Löhr, G. and Michel, C. (2022) "Predictive Processing And The Semiological Principle: Commentary To Duffley", Manuscrito, v. 45, n. 1, 5-20.

Recanati, F. (2010), Truth-conditional Pragmatics, Oxford, Clarendon Press.




Como Citar

DUFFLEY, P. . Reply to “predictive processing and the semiological principle:: commentary to duffley”. Manuscrito: Revista Internacional de Filosofia, Campinas, SP, v. 45, n. 1, p. 21–27, 2022. Disponível em: Acesso em: 2 dez. 2022.