Keywords
Foundations of natural right
Deduction
Right
Morality
How to Cite
Abstract
Fichte’s ambitious project in the Foundations of Natural Right is to provide an a priori deduction of the concept of right independently from morality. So far, interpretations of Fichte’s deduction of the concept of right have persistently fallen into one of two rough categories: either they (re)interpret the normative necessity of right in terms of moral or quasi-moral normativity or they interpret right’s normative necessity in terms of hypothetical imperatives. However, each of these interpretations faces significant exegetical difficulties. By contrast, I argue that we can understand the normative necessity of right in terms of conceptual necessity. On this view, right does not tell us what ought to be done, but instead tells us what we are doing and have done. Not only does this provide for a promising philosophical account of the non-moral normativity of right, but also provides a compelling reading of Fichte’s text in both the deduction of the concept of right in the Foundations of Natural Right as well as his discussion of the application of the concept of right and coercion.
References
Bobbio, Norberto, 1965, ‘Law and Force’, The Monist 49(3), pp. 321-341
Clarke, James, 2016, ‘Fichte’s Independence Thesis,’ in Fichte's Foundations of Natural Right. A Critical Guide, edited by Gabriel Gottlieb, Cambridge University Press, pp. 52-71
Clarke, James, 2020a, ‘Deduction of Right,’ in in The Bloomsbury Handbook of Fichte, edited by Marina Bykova, Bloomsbury, pp. 433-440
Clarke, James, 2020b, ‘Separation of Right from Morality,’ in, edited by Marina Bykova, Bloomsbury, pp. 441-448
Darwall, Stephen, 2013, ‘Fichte and the Second-Person Standpoint,’ in Honor, History, and Relationship: Essays in Second-Personal Ethics II, Oxford University Press, pp. 222-246
Darwall, Stephen, 2014, ‘Why Fichte’s Second-Personal Foundations can provide a More Adequate Account of the Relation of Right than Kant’s,’ Grazer Philosophische Studien 90, pp. 5-20
De Pascale, Carla, 2003, „Die Vernunft ist praktisch.“ Fichte’s Ethik und Rechtslehre im System, translated by Stefan Monhardt, Berlin: Duncker & Humblot (originally published 1995 as Etica e diritto. La filosofia practica di Fichte e le sue ascendenze kantiane, Bologna: il Mulino)
Erhard, Johann Benjamin, 1795, ‘Apologie des Teufels,’ Philosophisches Journal einer Gesellschaft Teutscher Gelehrten, Neu-Strelitz: Hof, pp. 105-40
Erhard, Johann Benjamin, 1795, Über das Recht des Volks zu einer Revolution, Jena and Leipzig: Gabler
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, Hans Gliwitzky, Hans Jacob, Reinhard Lauth, Bayerische Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1962-, J.G. Fichte-Gesamtausgabe der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt: Friedrich Frommann Verlag
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, 1988, Fichte: Early Philosophical Writings, translated and edited by Daniel Breazeale, Ithaca: Cornell University Press
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, 1992, Foundations of Transcendental Philosophy: Wissenschaftslehre (nova methodo) (first published 1796/99), edited and translated by Daniel Breazeale, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, 1996, ‘Reclamation of the Freedom of Thought from the Princes of Europe, Who Have Oppressed It Until Now (1793),’ translated by Thomas E. Wartenberg, in What Is Enlightenment? Eighteenth-Century Answers and Twentieth-Century Questions, edited by James Schmidt, University of California Press, pp. 119-141
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, 2000, Foundations of Natural Right according to the Principles of the Wissenschaftslehre, edited by Frederick Neuhouser, translated by Michael Baur, Cambridge University Press [FNR]
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, 2005, The System of Ethics according to the Principles of the Wissenschaftslehre, translated and edited by Daniel Breazeale and Günter Zöller, Cambridge University Press [SE]
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb, 2021, Contribution to the Correction of the Public’s Judgments on the French Revolution, translated and edited by Jeffrey Church and Anna Marisa Schön, Albany: SUNY Press
Franks, Paul, 2005, All or Nothing: Systematicity, Transcendental Arguments, and Skepticism in German Idealism, Harvard University Press
Franks, Paul, 2006, ‘The Discovery of the Other: Cavell, Fichte, and skepticism,’ in Reading Cavell, edited by Alice Crary and Sanford Shieh, London: Routledge, pp. 166-203
Gottlieb, Gabriel, 2018, ‘A Family Quarrel: Fichte’s Deduction of Right and Recognition,’ in Kant and his German Contemporaries Volume II: Aesthetics, History, Politics, and Religion, edited by Daniel Dahlstrom, Cambridge University Press, pp. 170-192
James, David, 2016, ‘Fichte on Personal Freedom and the Freedom of Others,’ in Fichte's Foundations of Natural Right. A Critical Guide, edited by Gabriel Gottlieb, Cambridge University Press, pp. 177-195
Kelsen, Hans, 1934, ‘La Méthode et la Notion Fondamentale de la Théorie Pure du Droit’ Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale 41(2), pp. 183-204.
Kletzer, Christoph, 2013, ‘Primitive Law,’ Jurisprudence 4(2), pp. 263-272
Kletzer, Christoph, 2018, The Idea of a Pure Theory of Law, Oxford: Hart Publishing
Kersting, Wolfgang, 2001, “Die Unabhängigkeit des Rechts von der Moral (Einleitung),” in Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Grundlage des Naturrechts, edited by Jean-Christophe Merle, Berlin: Akademie Verlag, pp. 21-37
Kosch, Michelle, 2017, ‘Individuality and Rights in Fichte’s Ethics,’ Philosopher’s Imprint 17(12), pp. 1-23
Kosch, Michelle, 2021, ‘Fichte on Summons and Self-Consciousness,’ Mind 130(517), pp. 215-249
McNulty, Jacob, 2016, ‘Transcendental Philosophy and Intersubjectivity: Mutual Recognition as a Condition for the Possibility of Self‐Consciousness in Sections 1-3 of Fichte’s Foundations of Natural Right,’ European Journal of Philosophy 24(4), pp. 788-810
Nance, Michael, 2012, ‘Recognition, Freedom, and the Self in Fichte’s Foundations of Natural Right,’ European Journal of Philosophy 23(3), pp. 608-632
Nance, Michael, 2016, ‘Freedom, Coercion, and the Relation of Right,’ in Fichte's Foundations of Natural Right. A Critical Guide , edited by Gabriel Gottlieb, Cambridge University Press, pp. 196-217
Nance, Michael, 2021, ‘Fichte’s First Principle of Right,’ Fichte-Studien 49, pp. 248-266
Neuhouser, Frederick, 1994, ‘Fichte and the Relation between Right and Morality,’ in Fichte: Historical Context/Contemporary Controversies, edited by Daniel Breazeale and Tom Rockmore, Humanities Press, pp. 158-80
Neuhouser, Frederick, 2000, ‘Introduction,’ in Fichte, Foundations of Natural Right according to the Principles of the Wissenschaftslehre , edited by Frederick Neuhouser, translated by Michael Baur, Cambridge University Press, pp. vii-xxviii
Neuhouser, Frederick, 2016, ‘Fichte’s Separation of Right from Morality,’ inFichte's Foundations of Natural Right. A Critical Guide , edited by Gabriel Gottlieb, Cambridge University Press, pp. 32-51
Nomer, Nedim, 2010, ‘Fichte and the Relationship between Self-Positing and Rights,’ Journal of the History of Philosophy, 48(3), pp. 469-490
Nomer, Nedim, 2020, ‘Are There Any Moral Rights for Fichte?’ in The Bloomsbury Handbook of Fichte, edited by Marina Bykova, Bloomsbury, pp. 449-455
Renaut, Alain, 1986, Le système du Droit: Philosophie et Droit dans la Pensée de Fichte, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France
Renaut, Alain, 1992, ‘Fichte: Le Droit Sans Morale?‘ Archives de Philosophie 55(2), pp. 221-242
Siep, Ludwig, 1979, Anerkennung als Prinzip der praktischen Philosophie: Untersuchungen zu Hegels Jenaer Philosophie des Geistes, Freiburg: Karl Alber
Siep, Ludwig, 1992a, ‘Naturrecht und Wissenschaftslehre,’ in Fichte’s Lehre vom Rechtsverhältnis: Die Deduktion der §§1-4 der Grundlage des Naturrechts und ihre Stellung in der Rechtsphilosophie, edited by Michael Kahlo, Ernst A. Wolff und Rainer Zaczyk , Frankfurt am Main: Vittorio Klostermann, pp. 71-91
Siep, Ludwig, 1992b, Praktische Philosophie im Deutschen Idealismus, Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp
Ware, Owen, 2009, ‘Fichte’s Voluntarism,’ European Journal of Philosophy 18(2), pp. 262-282
Williams, Robert, 2002, ‘The Displacement of Recognition by Coercion in Fichte’s Grundlage des Naturrechts,’ in New Essays on Fichte’s Later Jena Wissenschaftslehre, edited by Daniel Breazeale and Tom Rockmore, Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, pp. 47-64
Wood, Allen, 1990, Hegel’s Ethical Thought, Cambridge University Press
Wood, Allen, 2016a, Fichte’s Ethical Thought, Oxford University Press
Wood, Allen, 2016b, ‘Deduction of the Summons and the Existence of Other Rational Beings,’ in Fichte’s Foundations of Natural Right: A Critical Guide, edited by Gabriel Gottlieb, Cambridge University Press, pp. 72-91
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2023 Manuscrito: International Journal of Philosophy
Downloads
